Online Now 527

Wolverine247 Board

The place for discussion on the Michigan Wolverines

On this Board 348
Record: 2671 (1/26/2013)

Online now 568
Record: 7264 (3/12/2012)

Reply

Will Meyer be left with scraps at OL?

  • dukeluke said...

    I've now realized the key to Michigan's OL recruiting: Zingerman's. I was up in Ann Arbor for the last week, probably gained 5 lbs from Zingerman's alone. Too good, too good.

    roflmao

    signature image signature image signature image

    fursty13

  • I haven't seen much talk about recruiting the type of OL you need for your style of offense. Everywhere meyer has coached he has had a good offense. His spread style requires a different type of OL than Hoke's. They just went undefeated with a line that was ranked worse than any he will ever recruit while at osu. He just beat michigan with the worst set of offensive palymakers he will ever have at osu. He has never had high numbers at OL. You only play five and they usually don't come out unless injured. When you start to look at the quality and depth of the dl at osu vs michigan i don't know how you aren't worried. You might have 15 OL that are awesome but only 5 can play at a time. The more they play together, the better they usually are. All Meyer needs to have is five players out of 4 classes. DL can rotate and stay fresh. He just turned a tight end into an NFL Tackle. Two of the underperforming DTs are switching to OG. They could very well dominate on offense. DTs tend to be more athletic and nastier than OL.

    Responding to an earlier post, the reason LSU doesn't win is becasue their coaching staff sucks at recruiting and developing QBs. As good as their defense is, their offense can never score vs quality teams. They would be right with Alabama if they had a better qb and offensive plan.

    HotSauce

  • HotSauce said...

    I haven't seen much talk about recruiting the type of OL you need for your style of offense. Everywhere meyer has coached he has had a good offense. His spread style requires a different type of OL than Hoke's. They just went undefeated with a line that was ranked worse than any he will ever recruit while at osu. He just beat michigan with the worst set of offensive palymakers he will ever have at osu. He has never had high numbers at OL. You only play five and they usually don't come out unless injured. When you start to look at the quality and depth of the dl at osu vs michigan i don't know how you aren't worried. You might have 15 OL that are awesome but only 5 can play at a time. The more they play together, the better they usually are. All Meyer needs to have is five players out of 4 classes. DL can rotate and stay fresh. He just turned a tight end into an NFL Tackle. Two of the underperforming DTs are switching to OG. They could very well dominate on offense. DTs tend to be more athletic and nastier than OL.

    Responding to an earlier post, the reason LSU doesn't win is becasue their coaching staff sucks at recruiting and developing QBs. As good as their defense is, their offense can never score vs quality teams. They would be right with Alabama if they had a better qb and offensive plan.

    And Hoke just went against Meyer with the worst OL he will have in his tenure. The worst group of RBs, the worst set of CBs, a QB who had only been at QB for 3 weeks. The DL was mediocre and could not pressure a quarterback and the DBs were slow and awful in coverage. Give me a break. I'll take an OL that can get me 5 on the ground every play all day. Michigan has Shane Morris coming in, and regardless of what OSU FANS say, there's a reason he's a consensus top QB. Look at Tom Brady and the Patriots right now. The OL is great, but outside of Brady, there's not a ton of talent. Sure, Gronk and Hernandez are great, but they don't have the "speed" OSU fans love referencing. Brady makes them look great and they can consistently run the ball. And as for your "maybe sort of probably" the DTs will become great OGs, the likelihood is slim. Will Campbell was switched to guard while Rodriguez was coach, and was switched back by Hoke because the move was so idiotic.

    signature image signature image signature image

    fursty13

  • fursty13 said...

    And Hoke just went against Meyer with the worst OL he will have in his tenure. The worst group of RBs, the worst set of CBs, a QB who had only been at QB for 3 weeks. The DL was mediocre and could not pressure a quarterback and the DBs were slow and awful in coverage. Give me a break. I'll take an OL that can get me 5 on the ground every play all day. Michigan has Shane Morris coming in, and regardless of what OSU FANS say, there's a reason he's a consensus top QB. Look at Tom Brady and the Patriots right now. The OL is great, but outside of Brady, there's not a ton of talent. Sure, Gronk and Hernandez are great, but they don't have the "speed" OSU fans love referencing. Brady makes them look great and they can consistently run the ball. And as for your "maybe sort of probably" the DTs will become great OGs, the likelihood is slim. Will Campbell was switched to guard while Rodriguez was coach, and was switched back by Hoke because the move was so idiotic.

    I agree with what you are saying. I don't think osu is ready to blow Michigan away or anything. I actually think the two teams Are getting better vs the rest of the league. My point is that um recruiting all these OL is great but osu will also have pretty good OL play if you consider Meyers history and recruiting. He just does it differently. I don't think it's going to be an Alabama vs nd situation like some other posters seem to.
    I think depth at dl is more useful than depth At OL provided you have five who can play because you usually rotate more dl than OL.

    HotSauce

  • HotSauce said...

    I agree with what you are saying. I don't think osu is ready to blow Michigan away or anything. I actually think the two teams Are getting better vs the rest of the league. My point is that um recruiting all these OL is great but osu will also have pretty good OL play if you consider Meyers history and recruiting. He just does it differently. I don't think it's going to be an Alabama vs nd situation like some other posters seem to.
    I think depth at dl is more useful than depth At OL provided you have five who can play because you usually rotate more dl than OL.

    Agreed. It will be like Alabama vs. ND for the rest of the conference for OSu and Michigan. Then the final game of the season will be Bama vs. LSU in my opinion.

    signature image signature image signature image

    fursty13

  • HotSauce said...

    I agree with what you are saying. I don't think osu is ready to blow Michigan away or anything. I actually think the two teams Are getting better vs the rest of the league. My point is that um recruiting all these OL is great but osu will also have pretty good OL play if you consider Meyers history and recruiting. He just does it differently. I don't think it's going to be an Alabama vs nd situation like some other posters seem to.
    I think depth at dl is more useful than depth At OL provided you have five who can play because you usually rotate more dl than OL.

    OL generally take longer and are harder to develop. An elite DE can come in and be very productive as a FR or RS FR. That rarely works on the OL. Hoke is doing the right thing by making OL a high priority and OSU easily might find themselves in a dangerously thin position in a couple of years if they don't get their OL recruiting on track soon.

    MrWoodson

  • fursty13 said...

    Agreed. It will be like Alabama vs. ND for the rest of the conference for OSu and Michigan. Then the final game of the season will be Bama vs. LSU in my opinion.

    I can't wait. The B1G is just better when OSU and UM are dominating everybody else. 2006 was the best season I can remember until that awful title game. That was a wakeup call to the whole league. "The Game" could have gone either way. We both destroyed everybody else in the league and then got waxed in our bowl games. I think this time we both have bigger goals. Both our coaches and recruiting are better. We (OSU and UM) are going to dominate the B1G and then at least compete and win our share of matchups with the nation's best. It should be a wild seven to ten years.

    This post was edited by HotSauce on 1/13/2013 at 6:20 PM

    HotSauce

  • MrWoodson said...

    OL generally take longer and are harder to develop. An elite DE can come in and be very productive as a FR or RS FR. That rarely works on the OL. Hoke is doing the right thing by making OL a high priority and OSU easily might find themselves in a dangerously thin position in a couple of years if they don't get their OL recruiting on track soon.

    IMO 2014 OL recruiting for OSU will be huge. If we strike out with the 2014 class, we're in trouble. If Meyer brings in 3-4 4* OL, I think we're in good shape. He got the first one in Marcelys Jones, but Jones was a lock the same way Evan Lisle was. The real test will be the OOS OL like Rod Johnson, Jamarco Jones, Orlando Brown, etc. To this point he hasn't been able to grab that kind of top OOS OL at OSU.

    dukeluke

  • dukeluke said...

    IMO 2014 OL recruiting for OSU will be huge. If we strike out with the 2014 class, we're in trouble. If Meyer brings in 3-4 4* OL, I think we're in good shape. He got the first one in Marcelys Jones, but Jones was a lock the same way Evan Lisle was. The real test will be the OOS OL like Rod Johnson, Jamarco Jones, Orlando Brown, etc. To this point he hasn't been able to grab that kind of top OOS OL at OSU.

    Agreed.

    It is interesting though. Urban has focused on big time skill players, and done relatively well. Hoke has focused on OL/DL and done relatively well. The question is whether each can broaden that intensity.

    www.neoavatara.com/blog

    neoavatara

  • And people called me a OSU fan in the game thread today......as there is a 53 page thread on who their slimeball coach is recruiting at OL blank

    signature image signature image signature image

    sircharles11

  • I agree with what you are saying. I don't think osu is ready to blow Michigan away or anything. I actually think the two teams Are getting better vs the rest of the league. My point is that um recruiting all these OL is great but osu will also have pretty good OL play if you consider Meyers history and recruiting. He just does it differently. I don't think it's going to be an Alabama vs nd situation like some other posters seem to.
    I think depth at dl is more useful than depth At OL provided you have five who can play because you usually rotate more dl than OL.

    HotSauce

  • neoavatara said...

    Agreed.

    It is interesting though. Urban has focused on big time skill players, and done relatively well. Hoke has focused on OL/DL and done relatively well. The question is whether each can broaden that intensity.

    Actually Meyer has done great with the DL. His first two classes were both arguably the top DL classes in the nation. He hasn't done enough to beef up our OL yet....the best thing he did was adding Warriner (from ND) to the staff. He transformed ND's Oline and did a great job in his first year with our Oline...our best Oline in YEARS. Hopefully this development will progress and our Oline will continue to improve.

    I'm not a Hoke believer, I just don't think he's the guy to get you guys back to where you need to be, but the guy can definitely recruit OLinemen...what is he doing? Promising these guys red zone targets??

    NJDF

  • NJDF said...

    Actually Meyer has done great with the DL. His first two classes were both arguably the top DL classes in the nation. He hasn't done enough to beef up our OL yet....the best thing he did was adding Warriner (from ND) to the staff. He transformed ND's Oline and did a great job in his first year with our Oline...our best Oline in YEARS. Hopefully this development will progress and our Oline will continue to improve.

    I'm not a Hoke believer, I just don't think he's the guy to get you guys back to where you need to be, but the guy can definitely recruit OLinemen...what is he doing? Promising these guys red zone targets??

    I actually meant it as a focus on OL. The DL comment was more about Hoke's targets. Agreed, he has recruited DL well.

    www.neoavatara.com/blog

    neoavatara

  • Here's a reality check for Ohio fans:

    In 2009, Urban Meyer's Florida team had the following players in its 2 deep:

    - QB Tim Tebow
    - TE Aaron Hernandez (Pro-Bowl)
    - C Maurkice Pouncey (Pro-Bowl)
    - OG Mike Pouncey
    - WR Riley Cooper
    - LB Brandon Spikes
    - CB Major Wright
    - DE Carlos Dunlap
    - DE Jermaine Cunningham
    - CB Joe Haden
    - WR Chris Rainey
    - S Will Hill
    - CB Ahmad Black
    - CB Janoris Jenkins

    I'm probably forgetting a few names but that's at least 14 current NFL players from the 2009 Florida team who play (or have played meaningful snaps) at the pro level.

    The 2009 team did not have Percy Harvin or Louis Murphy from the 2008 team but it was was one year older.

    That 2009 team lost 32-13 to Alabama.

    It is unlikely that Meyer's future Ohio teams will be more loaded then his Florida teams. He built his Florida teams when Bobby Bowden was a lame duck coach at FSU and while Miami suffered through Randy Shannon. In other words, he was able to snag more Florida talent with less competition from in-state rivals.

    After Meyer's 2009 team was beaten convincingly 32-13 in the 2009 SEC Title game and after Meyer's 2010 team was crushed 31-6 in Tuscaloosa, the Saban-Alabama dynasty forced Urban Meyer into early retirement.

    Thankfully, Michigan's bread and butter is similar to Alabama's pro-style which gave Meyer/Florida so much trouble.

    While Ohio fans are probably convinced that Meyer/Ohio will run the B1G, I think they should avoid being overconfident.

    This post has been edited 2 times, most recently by Frank C on 1/13/2013 at 10:55 PM

    signature image

    Frank C

  • neoavatara said...

    Agreed.

    It is interesting though. Urban has focused on big time skill players, and done relatively well. Hoke has focused on OL/DL and done relatively well. The question is whether each can broaden that intensity.

    What big time skill players? Unless you are talking about defense, the only ones I see in OSU's 2013 class are Barrett, Elliott and Marshall. In comparison, we have Morris and Smith and have a very good chance of landing Derrick Green. We missed on the one truly elite WR we were after (LaQuon Treadwell), but OSU fans somehow seem to think they are pulling a ton of elite offensive skill players while we aren't pulling any. It's borderline laughable. If we land a couple of elite WRs in 2014, we will have everything we need on offense. And FWIW I believe Derrick Green is going to be much more productive in our offense than Ezekiel Elliott is in theirs. If we miss on Green, then I will begin to worry a little.

    MrWoodson

  • Frank C said...

    Here's a reality check for Ohio fans:

    In 2009, Urban Meyer's Florida team had the following players in its 2 deep:

    - QB Tim Tebow - TE Aaron Hernandez (Pro-Bowl) - C Maurkice Pouncey (Pro-Bowl) - OG Mike Pouncey - WR Riley Cooper - LB Brandon Spikes - CB Major Wright - DE Carlos Dunlap - DE Jermaine Cunningham - CB Joe Haden - WR Chris Rainey - S Will Hill - CB Ahmad Black - CB Janoris Jenkins

    I'm probably forgetting a few names but that's at least 14 current NFL players from the 2009 Florida team who play (or have played meaningful snaps) at the pro level.

    The 2009 teams did not have Percy Harvin or Louis Murphy from the 2008 team but was one year older.

    That team lost 32-13 to Alabama.

    It is unlikely that Meyer's future Ohio teams will be more loaded then his Florida teams. He built his Florida teams when Bobby Bowden was a lame duck coach at FSU and while Miami suffered through Randy Shannon. In other words, he was able to snag more Florida talent with less competition from in-state rivals.

    After Meyer's 2009 team was beaten convincingly 32-13 in the 2009 SEC Title game and after Meyer's 2010 team was crushed 31-6 in Tuscaloosa, the Saban-Alabama dynasty forced Urban Meyer into early retirement.

    Thankfully, Michigan's bread and butter is similar to Alabama's pro-style which gave Meyer/Florida so much trouble.

    While Ohio fans are probably convinced that Meyer/Ohio will run the B1G, I think they should avoid being overconfident.

    ....But.....but.....playmakers....

    In all seriousness though I agree with what you are saying. I think Michigan will have one of the few OL's in college football that could actually allow a team to run on Alabama. Michigan definitely needs more pieces to have a shot at beating Alabama though.

    hownowbrowncow

  • It's a common talking point amongst buckeye fans to say that we take in too many OL commits and how we can only play five. In what scenario is having quality depth on the O line ever a bad thing?

    "They can only play five!" Well yes that is true but what about when injuries happen? When a recruit doesn't turn out? The fact of the matter is no recruits success is guaranteed. We're on here gushing over all our recruits when the fact of the matter if there's at least a couple guys we're all jacked up about who wont do anything on the field. Having depth is what counteracts this. Not an attack to the poster who just brought this up because he was very respectful and made good points, just providing a response to this idea I see written on here all the time.

    Bottom line is, after four quarters power generally begins to beat speed. Considering that UM and OSU are basically recruiting at the same level for both of their respective systems, and seeing how Oregon's style hasn't exactly thrived against strong defenses, I like our chances.

    signature image signature image signature image

    mac1992

  • Frank C said...

    Here's a reality check for Ohio fans:

    In 2009, Urban Meyer's Florida team had the following players in its 2 deep:

    - QB Tim Tebow
    - TE Aaron Hernandez (Pro-Bowl)
    - C Maurkice Pouncey (Pro-Bowl)
    - OG Mike Pouncey
    - WR Riley Cooper
    - LB Brandon Spikes
    - CB Major Wright
    - DE Carlos Dunlap
    - DE Jermaine Cunningham
    - CB Joe Haden
    - WR Chris Rainey
    - S Will Hill
    - CB Ahmad Black
    - CB Janoris Jenkins

    I'm probably forgetting a few names but that's at least 14 current NFL players from the 2009 Florida team who play (or have played meaningful snaps) at the pro level.

    The 2009 team did not have Percy Harvin or Louis Murphy from the 2008 team but it was was one year older.

    That 2009 team lost 32-13 to Alabama.

    It is unlikely that Meyer's future Ohio teams will be more loaded then his Florida teams. He built his Florida teams when Bobby Bowden was a lame duck coach at FSU and while Miami suffered through Randy Shannon. In other words, he was able to snag more Florida talent with less competition from in-state rivals.

    After Meyer's 2009 team was beaten convincingly 32-13 in the 2009 SEC Title game and after Meyer's 2010 team was crushed 31-6 in Tuscaloosa, the Saban-Alabama dynasty forced Urban Meyer into early retirement.

    Thankfully, Michigan's bread and butter is similar to Alabama's pro-style which gave Meyer/Florida so much trouble.

    While Ohio fans are probably convinced that Meyer/Ohio will run the B1G, I think they should avoid being overconfident.

    I don't think anybody is saying that urban Meyer is better than saban. Meyer even says al is the gold standard and they know they have to get better each day with beating al as their goal.
    Your post seems to be putting hoke at Michigan on Saban's level trying to compare Meyers records vs saban In his last two years at fl. I think we all can agree that hoke is far away from saban. There are many teams that run a pro style offense. The only one that bothered Meyer is the one coached by saban. If you guys hire him, then we will start to worry.

    This post was edited by HotSauce on 1/14/2013 at 5:26 AM

    HotSauce

  • HotSauce said...

    I don't think anybody is saying that urban Meyer is better than saban. Meyer even says al is the gold standard and they know they have to get better each day with beating al as their goal. Your post seems to be putting hoke at Michigan on Saban's level trying to compare Meyers records vs saban In his last two years at fl. I think we all can agree that hoke is far away from saban. There are many teams that run a pro style offense. The only one that bothered Meyer is the one coached by saban. If you guys hire him, then we will start to worry.

    How was he putting Michigan on Alabama's level? He said that Michigan is going to be running the same offense that gave Meyer trouble. He never said that that put Michigan on Saban's level. I swear some people just read what they want to see. lol

    hownowbrowncow

  • elmn12 said...

    How was he putting Michigan on Alabama's level? He said that Michigan is going to be running the same offense that gave Meyer trouble. He never said that that put Michigan on Saban's level. I swear some people just read what they want to see. lol

    The post I quoted makes reference to saban beating Meyer with a pretty good team that ran the same style of offense that Michigan and hoke are now running. That is definitely making a connection between hoke and saban having success against Meyer. That is how he/she is putting them on the same level. I don't think any realistic fan thinks the bucks or any team is going to go in and have an easy time beating Alabama. I do think osu should have pretty high expectations of running the table in the conference the next few years and taking a shot at the sec champ in the playoffs. That's all you need is a chance.

    HotSauce

  • Rumor is OSU is losing a Freshman OL...

    www.neoavatara.com/blog

    neoavatara

  • neoavatara said...

    Rumor is OSU is losing a Freshman OL...

    pray

    signature image signature image signature image

    CMXI

  • Also, I've come up with a theme song for this thread:

    "This is the thread that never ends,
    And it goes on and on my friends,
    Urban keeps losing linemen because that's just what Urban does;
    And we'll continue posting here forever just because..."

    [Repeat endlessly]

    biggrin

    signature image signature image signature image

    CMXI

  • neoavatara said...

    Rumor is OSU is losing a Freshman OL...

    It's Joey O'Conner

    signature image

    Rabid

  • RabidWolverine said...

    It's Joey O'Conner

    Where'd you hear this? Also, do you know any particular reason why?

    signature image signature image signature image

    CMXI