Online Now 1146

Wolverine247 Board

The place for discussion on the Michigan Wolverines

On this Board 663
Record: 2671 (1/26/2013)

Online now 951
Record: 7264 (3/12/2012)

Reply

The ethical difference between Michigan and Ohio

  • TimBucktoo said...

    I imagine had ****igan miraculously won the game (it no longer deserves capitalization stepchildren) this post would not exist and in its place a bunch of gloating and chest puffery.

    Anyhoo, I am very familiar with what "disassociation" means; however, that is not my point. My question to you is did Michigan disassociate itself willingly to uphold some higher standard, or was it simply a proactive move to mitigate inevitable NCAA penalties? You can minimize ****igan' infractions (in your mind) all you'd like, but Martin paid significant sums of money to the Fab Five, and later Robert "Tractor" Traylor, over multiple years and gave them fairly expensive vehicles. True, Fisher was never implicated in the pay-to-play, but he was the most clueless person in Ann Arbor if he did not know what was going.

    I can be honest and admit Tressel cheated. As such, it is ridiculous for you to twist facts to make ****igan look cleaner (in your mind) than the Alabamas, Kentuckys, USCs, tOSUs, and other powerhouse programs in college sports.

    BTW, so much for integrity: http://jalenrose.com/press/members-of-michigans-fab-five-honored-at-crisler-arena-november-21-2010

    And so what it was 15 years after the violations. Pete Rose is still banned from baseball and it has been much longer. Just another irrelevant fact that you'll hold up to make ****igan appear holier than thou.

    Sir, with all due respect the difference is quite simple. The banners from the championships that the fab five collected during their time at Michigan are no longer in the rafters because of the improprieties that took place.

    Where is the memorabilia that OSU accumulated for the championships won by Tressel, Pryor and co.? (besides the stuff they sold)

    I don't know that is why I am asking, but If I had to guess probably hanging around or in a display somewhere around the stadium.

    Amazinglyblue78

  • I enjoy reading the things happening with our biggest rival. I understand many will always have a negative slant on Coach Tressel. Like many I have major issues with the way he conducted himself at the end of his time. I don't think he was/is a bad person or was "unethical" for ten years. I think the NCAA and Sports Illustrated dug deep and hard after the National Championship and found nothing they could pin on the program as a "major violation".

    I do believe Tressel sold his sole to the devil for Pryor. Lost control. It happens to good people sometimes when they get to greedy. The bowl ban is deserved, the punishment fits the crime. However, I can separate what the program did in 02 from the things Tressel did in the last yr(s) of the program.

    I've read some reports recently that say Tress has lost weight, looks healthy, is less stressed, and happy. Those things make me believe even more that Tressel sold out. And it was not the person he is, but allowed expectations to overtake his values. Just my 2 pennies. Good luck in your Bowl.

    but_why_not

  • xxmgobluexx said...

    tOSU just played a meaningless season.

    so did Michigan!

    Crazynut

  • We get it. Tress lied to the NCAA. That is bad and he got what he deserved.

    That said, he has done amazing philanthropic work in the community. He has been adored by almost all him players for the way he mentored them. He did great work encouraging athletes in the classroom. And he led the program into an unparalleled ten years. His ending was shameful, his body of work was praiseworthy.Just a little actual rationale for those of you who can't seem to see the forest through the trees.

    AllDay28

  • Crazynut said...

    so did Michigan!

    Why? What purpose does this serve, other than to make us look bad on an opposing teams site! If they did this on Bucknuts posters such as yourself would go into a profanity laced tirade! Can we stop please. Post with some substance or stay home!

    Soap Box <-------Stepping down now.........

    but_why_not

  • elmn12 said...

    Too bad no one cares that Ohio finished 12-0. You guys should be happy that the toughest team you played was Michigan, because if you ran into an SEC team in a bowl game you would just embarrass yourselves again. At least this way you can keep lying to yourselves. lol

    When you say SEC team you mean Alabama don't you. I watched the Bama - Michigan gamem and you guys had a healthy backfield then, you guys loked awesome against Bama, now that was embarrassment my friend. As far as nobody cares that THE OHIO STATE went 12-0 I think you may find a few people that were happy. Oh by the way, I just sent Hoke a check for $1000.00 to buy a headset for the games and a box of twinkies.

    horseshoefreak

  • horseshoefreak said...

    When you say SEC team you mean Alabama don't you. I watched the Bama - Michigan gamem and you guys had a healthy backfield then, you guys loked awesome against Bama, now that was embarrassment my friend. As far as nobody cares that THE OHIO STATE went 12-0 I think you may find a few people that were happy. Oh by the way, I just sent Hoke a check for $1000.00 to buy a headset for the games and a box of twinkies.

    Fitz didn't play againt Bama...not that I believe it would have mattered.

    And frankly...I think Bama would beat you guys by two touchdowns, at least.

    www.neoavatara.com/blog

    neoavatara

  • Awink2 said...

    Actually, the AP natty we won in '97 is more prestigious then the coaches poll

    Who says ap is more prestigious? Coaches poll is actually still used in the bcs. AP is what Ohio state could have won this year.

    My point in 1997 is that Michigan didn't beat the best team in the country that year. They didn't even play them. Nebraska was widely considered the best team and got hosed by having to share with a Michigan team that didn't beat anyone.

    HotSauce

  • AllDay28 said...

    We get it. Tress lied to the NCAA. That is bad and he got what he deserved.

    That said, he has done amazing philanthropic work in the community. He has been adored by almost all him players for the way he mentored them. He did great work encouraging athletes in the classroom. And he led the program into an unparalleled ten years. His ending was shameful, his body of work was praiseworthy.Just a little actual rationale for those of you who can't seem to see the forest through the trees.

    Joe Paterno did good things for the community too. How'd that turn out?

    Not saying what Tressel did was as bad as Paterno, but he still did them. It's only been a year and half or so and almost everyone at osu acts like it never happened. Why would you honor the guy that's responsible for you not playing for a national championship this year?

    UMWolverines

  • UMWolverines said...

    Joe Paterno did good things for the community too. How'd that turn out?

    Not saying what Tressel did was as bad as Paterno, but he still did them. It's only been a year and half or so and almost everyone at osu acts like it never happened. Why would you honor the guy that's responsible for you not playing for a national championship this year?

    You compare him to Joe Paterno and then say you aren't comparing them. It's disingenuous. Clearly they are different situations as this is seen by most as a "victimless crime". Sure, you can say this team is the victim but all those that are on the team now that played for him have consistently backed him, so I'll let them decide on that part.

    As far as the game, the honor was specifically for the 02 NC team. Not for Tress himself. The players of that team decided to hoist him up but the stadium was already giving a standing ovation. It was the ten year anniversary so it made sense time wise. It's not like they went out of their way to get him in here this year. But he deserves to be honored for that accomplishment just like all those players did.

    AllDay28

  • blue2468 said...

    I saw we are projected to the Capital One bowl.

    But not going to a bowl game and facing a team that is comparable to yours and actually PROVING something is very meaningless. What have you proved? You went undefeated against a very weak B1G, and that's it.

    I don't understand your argument here. TOSU went 8-0 in a " very weak B1G". Um went 6-2 in the same conference, without playing Wisconsin or Penn State.

    signature image

    An Ohioan by birth, a Buckeye by the grace of God.

    BuckeyeinGa2003

  • AllDay28 said...

    You compare him to Joe Paterno and then say you aren't comparing them. It's disingenuous. Clearly they are different situations as this is seen by most as a "victimless crime". Sure, you can say this team is the victim but all those that are on the team now that played for him have consistently backed him, so I'll let them decide on that part.

    As far as the game, the honor was specifically for the 02 NC team. Not for Tress himself. The players of that team decided to hoist him up but the stadium was already giving a standing ovation. It was the ten year anniversary so it made sense time wise. It's not like they went out of their way to get him in here this year. But he deserves to be honored for that accomplishment just like all those players did.

    I never said I wasn't comparing them...

    UMWolverines

  • UMWolverines said...

    I never said I wasn't comparing them...

    We'll I'm sure all those boys who were assaulted would appreciate that comparison.

    AllDay28

  • elmn12 said...

    Too bad no one cares that Ohio finished 12-0. You guys should be happy that the toughest team you played was Michigan, because if you ran into an SEC team in a bowl game you would just embarrass yourselves again. At least this way you can keep lying to yourselves. lol

    In 10 years Ohio State will be celebrating Meyer's undefeated 2012 Buckeyes. I wonder if UM will be doing the same with their 2012 that had an 8-4 record, a second place divisional finish, and a second tier bowl game

    Bell68

  • AllDay28 said...

    We'll I'm sure all those boys who were assaulted would appreciate that comparison.

    I'm sure most of the buckeye fans still think Tressel is a hero too because he beat michigan and that's all that matters

    UMWolverines

  • Nutcracker said...

    biggrin Ha, I will, thanks for the advice. My advice to you is, I don't know, well there isn't much you can actually do. Maybe take some logic classes?

    Wow nice comeback guy..

    bucky34

  • UMWolverines said...

    I'm sure most of the buckeye fans still think Tressel is a hero too because he beat michigan and that's all that matters

    I just told you why he is a hero to buckeye fans. Winning is certainly part of the equation. He made a victimless mistake and paid dearly for it. That doesn't mean that the rest of the great things he did on and off the field don't deserve praise. Comparing him to someone who had a part in the sexual assault of many young boys is, at best, disingenuous.

    AllDay28

  • Bell68 said...

    In 10 years Ohio State will be celebrating Meyer's undefeated 2012 Buckeyes. I wonder if UM will be doing the same with their 2012 that had an 8-4 record, a second place divisional finish, and a second tier bowl game

    I never realized that the capital one or outback are second tier bowl games? Besides the bcs bowls, the capital one is the best bowl game out there and outback the 3rd best imo. Second tier is more like the motor city bowl I would think. Just like the MAC is a second tier conference to the Big Ten. Enjoy your 12-0 record but realize it doesn't hold much weight considering Alabama, LSU, Georgia, Texas a&m, Florida, and South Carolina would beat you silly. Before your BP raises I think we would loose as well. I will enjoy the practices we get from the bowl, the help with recruiting, and being able to watch my team in another game. Enjoy your 12-0 season that should have ended as soon as Cal if the refs didnt make the holding call on the cal TE which brought back a touchdown, and was your biggest non conference game FYI they are 3-9. If you guys are not 11-0 coming into the game next year Urb should be on the hot seat, what a joke of a schedule.

    signature image

    LEXwolverine1

  • AllDay28 said...

    I just told you why he is a hero to buckeye fans. Winning is certainly part of the equation. He made a victimless mistake and paid dearly for it. That doesn't mean that the rest of the great things he did on and off the field don't deserve praise. Comparing him to someone who had a part in the sexual assault of many young boys is, at best, disingenuous.

    How exactly is he paying for it dearly?

    UMWolverines

  • LEXwolverine1 said...

    I never realized that the capital one or outback are second tier bowl games? Besides the bcs bowls, the capital one is the best bowl game out there and outback the 3rd best imo. Second tier is more like the motor city bowl I would think. Just like the MAC is a second tier conference to the Big Ten. Enjoy your 12-0 record but realize it doesn't hold much weight considering Alabama, LSU, Georgia, Texas a&m, Florida, and South Carolina would beat you silly. Before your BP raises I think we would loose as well. I will enjoy the practices we get from the bowl, the help with recruiting, and being able to watch my team in another game. Enjoy your 12-0 season that should have ended as soon as Cal if the refs didnt make the holding call on the cal TE which brought back a touchdown, and was your biggest non conference game FYI they are 3-9. If you guys are not 11-0 coming into the game next year Urb should be on the hot seat, what a joke of a schedule.

    Admittedly, our schedule was soft this year; however, I'd take a soft 12-0 than 8-4 with a couple of ugly losses (14-41 vs. Alabama, no touchdown vs. ND) sprinkled in. Say what you like but we beat Nebraska and we beat you, so if we're soft what does that say about you?

    TimBucktoo

  • I find it hilarious all these suckeyes are coming in here thumping their chests thinking they're world beaters. Their OOC schedule is pathetic with Miami OH, Cal, UCF and UAB! There is absolutely ZERO competition there, on top of getting us and Neb at home. On top of this, they squeaked by Cal, Purdue AND Indiana yet think they are some juggernaught? Give me a frickin break! ND or any of the SEC giants would stomp a mudhole in that arse just like Bama did to us. If they can't admit that than they're just lying to themselves. Be very happy you dont have to play another one if you like flaunting the weakest undefeated season I can ever remember

    TommyTurner

  • TommyTurner said...

    I find it hilarious all these suckeyes are coming in here thumping their chests thinking they're world beaters. Their OOC schedule is pathetic with Miami OH, Cal, UCF and UAB! There is absolutely ZERO competition there, on top of getting us and Neb at home. On top of this, they squeaked by Cal, Purdue AND Indiana yet think they are some juggernaught? Give me a frickin break! ND or any of the SEC giants would stomp a mudhole in that arse just like Bama did to us. If they can't admit that than they're just lying to themselves. Be very happy you dont have to play another one if you like flaunting the weakest undefeated season I can ever remember

    Their schedule next year isn't much better. I'd be shocked if they lost more than one game next year going into The Game.

    UMWolverines

  • Call OSu cheaters while you still can before you losers get busted for similar violations that the tat 5 did. Your players are no saints NCAA wise i know this first hand with my own eyes and money.

    OSU2002

  • TimBucktoo said...

    Admittedly, our schedule was soft this year; however, I'd take a soft 12-0 than 8-4 with a couple of ugly losses (14-41 vs. Alabama, no touchdown vs. ND) sprinkled in. Say what you like but we beat Nebraska and we beat you, so if we're soft what does that say about you?

    Never said you were soft and I would take a 12-0 as well. My point is you guys need to come back down from Lucy and those diamonds and realize this team of yours got lucky on many occasions and is a good but no where close to being great team. I get it you beat us... As you should. This Michigan team has been dealing with attrition for 5 years thanks to RR. You guys have more talent and athletes across the board along with better depth. Our starting QB couldn't throw and our running back is on crutches along with our best cover man. You beat us by 5 at your place. You guys got the win, you deserve to brag for the next year, the spoils of war! But any of you who think hoke and company are bad coaches and this will be the same when Carr was on his way out and RR didn't know the significance of the game you got another thing commin. I don't give a crap about Tressel and the thread topic, he's a scumbag and everyone knows it. He's been cheatin way before ever coming to OSU. You guys got what you deserved, if you guys still wanna get on your hands and knees and take it from him that's your problem.

    signature image

    LEXwolverine1

  • Awink2 said...

    A striking difference became apparent on Saturday between the two programs. It involved the glorification of a coach who swept NCAA rules under the rug, and who represents everything that collegiate athletics should not be. The Ohio faithful fawned over a man who attempted to manipulate a system by trying cover up any improprieties within a program he oversaw. A man who clearly conflated the line of what is right and wrong, while mentoring 18-23 year olds while in the process This was absolutely sickening to watch. What an excellent example to follow and be associated with......someone who embodies the hypocrisy of integrity.

    I will stand and clap like a SOB when the Fab 5 are brought back.

    signature image signature image signature image

    RicoX19