Online Now 1524

Wolverine247 Board

The place for discussion on the Michigan Wolverines

On this Board 951
Record: 2671 (1/26/2013)

Online now 1308
Record: 7264 (3/12/2012)

Reply

Rivals Analysts (4/5) have Garnett going to Stanford

  • http://footballrecruiting.rivals.com/content.asp?SID=880&CID=1322138

    signature image

    Go Blue!

    SBGoBlue

  • Oh well.... Have to wait until Thursday... Hemholdt has always been a pessimist with Michigan though.

    jnewberg24

  • jnewberg24 said...

    Oh well.... Have to wait until Thursday... Hemholdt has always been a pessimist with Michigan though.

    Reason why it puzzles me, is everything seems to be in Michigan's favor. I'd think at least half and half. Do they know something we don't? Who knows...

    signature image

    Go Blue!

    SBGoBlue

  • 4 out of 5 dentists chew Trident.

    signature image signature image signature image

    MSU isn't a very good football program.. takes year of consistent winning to get to that level. - copemoney 1/22/13

    Due51

  • sbarnes said...

    Reason why it puzzles me, is everything seems to be in Michigan's favor. I'd think at least half and half. Do they know something we don't? Who knows...

    From the very beginning, virtually all analysts, including the ones on this site, have said Banner and Garnett will both stay on the West Coast. It's only been in the last month that a few have started to change their tone on Garnett and those analysts are ones who have been traditionally closer to Michigan and/or Midwest recruiting. I think we get Diamond (and I think that because I think Caleb Stacey's switch to Cincy removed the only major obstacle to that decision). In fact, I think Diamond is the silent commit. I also think we get Sam Grant, based on hints by Sam Webb and TomVH. After that, it gets tougher. I think we had a very slight edge for Garnett, but that was before his visit to Stanford last weekend. Right now, I'd call it a coin flip. Pretty much the same with Reeves. I think we had the clear advantage until Camren Williams chose OSU. Now, I would call that one a coin flip.

    This post was edited by MrWoodson on 1/23/2012 at 1:32 PM

    MrWoodson

  • sbarnes said...

    http://footballrecruiting.rivals.com/content.asp?SID=880&CID=1322138

    Well rivals guys don't know left from right. Garnett - UM welcomes you. ' Come on down ' ,!

    signature image signature image signature image

    # NOTRE LAME SUCKS

    Brady 6

  • sbarnes said...

    Reason why it puzzles me, is everything seems to be in Michigan's favor. I'd think at least half and half. Do they know something we don't? Who knows...

    Most of the analysts on Scout and Rivals have been saying for 6 months that Garnett would end up at Stanford. So they aren't going to change their minds now. Stanford is closer, same time zone, has games in his home-state every year, weather is better, and academics are incredible. The thing to remember though is that Garnett is not tipping his hand to reporters. So those are purely guesses going off that data I just mentioned.

    I won't be shocked by either school getting picked.

    Dizzo

  • I'm going to go to my happy place and say he's favoring Michigan due to the stuff he posts on twitter. Also, didn't one of his friends from Stanford decide to leave for the NFL?

    otwp12

  • otwp12 said...

    I'm going to go to my happy place and say he's favoring Michigan due to the stuff he posts on twitter. Also, didn't one of his friends from Stanford decide to leave for the NFL?

    DeCastro... No clue how much of a benefit he was but I don't think it was a huge gain or loss for him

    jnewberg24

  • By probability, I would never as an analyst pick a west guy going to the midwest. It just doesn't happen that much.

    Of course, i think Garnett is the exception.

    www.neoavatara.com/blog

    neoavatara

  • Will be disappointed if he ends up at Stanford but you can't go wrong with either choice. He's a good kid and any school would be lucky to have him representing them.

    MaizeKC

  • Brady 6 said...

    Well rivals guys don't know left from right. Garnett - UM welcomes you. ' Come on down ' ,!

    Exactly this. These guys are often wrong with these late commitments as often as they are right.

    This post was edited by WarhawkMO on 1/23/2012 at 3:12 PM

    We may win We may lose But we always bleed Maize and Blue HAIL!!!!!

    WarhawkMO

  • jnewberg24 said...

    Oh well.... Have to wait until Thursday... Hemholdt has always been a pessimist with Michigan though.

    I honestly can't stand that guy, never could, never will.

    What are his credentials as a talent evaluator/"analyst" by the way?

    Rivals sucks. Hate to say it, but they really, really suck.

    supermario9

  • Tremendous seemed to feel good about our chances. I'll roll with their prediction since they've recently spoken with him, and it fits my blue agenda.

    Garnett is really the only must get recruit left on the board IMO. Nothing against the other three, but this kid seems like a game changer.

    Norbit

  • Josh and Mike at Rivals annoy me beyond belief. They both have anti-Michigan feeling and when they are wrong they try to play it off as a huge surprise.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Damaged goods

    MaizeandBlue21

  • TomVH is being cryptic, which is always a good thing. I trust Tom over anyone in the business IMO.

    signature image signature image signature image

    mriderblue12

  • Norbit said...

    Tremendous seemed to feel good about our chances. I'll roll with their prediction since they've recently spoken with him, and it fits my blue agenda.

    Garnett is really the only must get recruit left on the board IMO. Nothing against the other three, but this kid seems like a game changer.

    I would add Armani Reeves to the must-get list, just because I think Hoke winning head-to-head against Urban would be huge.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Ducksworth

  • mriderblue12 said...

    TomVH is being cryptic, which is always a good thing. I trust Tom over anyone in the business IMO.

    agree. TomVH is great. I know he had to go to ESPN because they offered him a great job and it's a great company to work for, but man I freaking hate ESPN.

    I miss TomVH and the Mgoblog days, but I am happy for him that he finally "made" it and got the big gig at ESPN.

    I think TomVH just has a better feel for these kids and their situations and is more friendly with them. I think the kids like him, whereas that Josh Helmholdt guy is just dry, has no personality or sense of humor and the HS kids he interviews see him as sort of a a creepo or a weirdo- whereas they see TomVH as more of a buddy or something. TomVH seems to get the scoop and the deal before any of the other guys.

    supermario9

  • mriderblue12 said...

    TomVH is being cryptic, which is always a good thing. I trust Tom over anyone in the business IMO.

    Yup this also doesn't hurt.

    Quote from Brent Williams: “I know that they both envisioned going to college together, but I think that all changed when everything happened at Penn State. I can tell you that we have had the conversation about Cam going to Ohio State and Armani at Michigan.”

    signature image signature image signature image

    Damaged goods

    MaizeandBlue21

  • supermario9 said...

    agree. TomVH is great. I know he had to go to ESPN because they offered him a great job and it's a great company to work for, but man I freaking hate ESPN.

    I miss TomVH and the Mgoblog days, but I am happy for him that he finally "made" it and got the big gig at ESPN.

    I think TomVH just has a better feel for these kids and their situations and is more friendly with them. I think the kids like him, whereas that Josh Helmholdt guy is just dry, has no personality or sense of humor and the HS kids he interviews see him as sort of a a creepo or a weirdo- whereas they see TomVH as more of a buddy or something. TomVH seems to get the scoop and the deal before any of the other guys.

    Tom and Sam both do a great job of making friends with the recruits. Sam Webb is really close with Pipkins, Garnett, Magnuson, RJS, Kalis, and a bunch of the guys.

    Tom and Sam are the best in the biz as far as Michigan recruiting goes.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Ducksworth

  • maize&blue21 said...

    Yup this also doesn't hurt.

    Quote from Brent Williams: “I know that they both envisioned going to college together, but I think that all changed when everything happened at Penn State. I can tell you that we have had the conversation about Cam going to Ohio State and Armani at Michigan.”

    Who's Brent Williams?

    signature image signature image signature image

    Ducksworth

  • Ducksworth said...

    Tom and Sam both do a great job of making friends with the recruits. Sam Webb is really close with Pipkins, Garnett, Magnuson, RJS, Kalis, and a bunch of the guys.

    Tom and Sam are the best in the biz as far as Michigan recruiting goes.

    I was going to say, Sam is awesome as well.

    If Sam, TomVH, and Allen Trieu somehow formed a trio it would be unreal. Trieu is great for evaluations, Sam and Tom for getting the scoop.

    signature image signature image signature image

    mriderblue12

  • Ducksworth said...

    Who's Brent Williams?

    Just by the sounds of the quote I would assume their coach. Just a complete guess though.

    I am a lot more optimistic about Reeves then ever before, and landing him would be huge. I was counting out Reeves for sure, and hopefully I will eat some crow.

    signature image signature image signature image

    mriderblue12

  • Ducksworth said...

    Tom and Sam both do a great job of making friends with the recruits. Sam Webb is really close with Pipkins, Garnett, Magnuson, RJS, Kalis, and a bunch of the guys.

    Tom and Sam are the best in the biz as far as Michigan recruiting goes.

    Sam Webb has good info, but I don't like him either. He is waaaayyyyyy too much of a Michigan homer IMO and the guy has one of the most annoying voices ever- not a good radio voices. I tried listening to his radio show, but between that shmuck who is on it with him, his total Michigan homerism, and his irritating voice....I just can't.

    I also hate that he sticks around at GoBlow and lets himself be used by that maniac Tom Beaver.

    TomVH is the best guy for Michigan related stuff...hands down....not even close.

    supermario9

  • Ducksworth said...

    Who's Brent Williams?

    Cam William's father who is also Armani's guardian

    signature image signature image signature image

    Damaged goods

    MaizeandBlue21